Table of Contents
As Somalia's dispute with the United Arab Emirates escalates, the Gulf Cooperation Council's chief official has entered the fray. His intervention raises uncomfortable questions about sovereignty, institutional impartiality and the selective defense of international norms.
A diplomatic quarrel between Somalia and the United Arab Emirates has erupted into an unusually sharp confrontation, exposing a deeper disagreement over sovereignty, foreign influence and the strategic ambitions of Gulf powers in the Horn of Africa. The dispute has now drawn in the Gulf Cooperation Council, whose Secretary-General appears to have chosen sides before seriously examining the grievances.
At the heart of the confrontation is a straightforward question: Can a state recognize another country's sovereignty while pursuing political, commercial and military arrangements within its territory against the express objections of its internationally recognized government?
Somalia believes the answer is no. Its government has repeatedly accused the UAE of bypassing federal institutions through agreements involving the strategic ports of Berbera, Bosaso and Kismayo, as well as supporting security structures outside national command. These allegations are longstanding, dating back to diplomatic complaints raised at the United Nations in 2018.
The latest escalation began on November 17th, when President Hassan Sheikh Mohamud publicly challenged Abu Dhabi's activities. Somalia's Foreign Ministry subsequently demanded an end to unauthorized foreign engagement, while senior Somali officials reinforced that position through public statements and social media. On November 19th, Mogadishu ordered the Emirati ambassador to leave within 72 hours and recalled its own envoy.
Abu Dhabi rejected the accusations. Anwar Gargash, adviser to the UAE president, characterized the Somali leader's complaints as driven by personal political considerations. The UAE Foreign Ministry described Somalia's diplomatic measures as hostile and escalatory, defending its longstanding assistance and cooperation with the Somali people.
Yet the Emirati response has largely sidestepped the substantive legal questions. Does a foreign government have the authority to conclude security arrangements with regional administrations without federal consent? Where does legitimate commercial cooperation end and interference in sovereign affairs begin? These questions cannot be dismissed merely by questioning the motives of Somalia's president or shrugging off as domestic divisions.
The dispute might have remained a difficult bilateral affair. Instead, an intervention from Riyadh has given it broader diplomatic significance.
On November 19th, Jasem Mohamed Albudaiwi, Secretary-General of the Gulf Cooperation Council, issued a strongly worded statement condemning what he described as irresponsible Somali government statements and malicious media campaigns targeting the UAE.
Rather than acknowledging Somalia's complaints or encouraging an examination of the disputed arrangements, Albudaiwi praised the UAE's contributions to international peace and security. He invoked its diplomatic efforts, including its hosting of Russian-Ukrainian talks, and emphasized the GCC's rejection of campaigns against member states.
The intervention was striking less for what it said than for what it omitted.
There was no substantive acknowledgment of Somalia's sovereignty concerns. No examination of the contested port and military agreements with regional authorities. No suggestion of mediation, independent inquiry or constructive dialogue between two governments that formally recognize one another and mutually embrace people to people historic relations.
Instead, the Secretary-General appeared to treat Somalia's complaints as an affront to the UAE's reputation rather than as allegations requiring serious consideration.
Such an approach risks confusing institutional solidarity with diplomatic impartiality. The GCC has every reason to defend the legitimate interests of its members. But defending a member state should not require dismissing another sovereign government's grievances before establishing whether they have merit.
There is also an important institutional distinction. Albudaiwi's statement was issued in his capacity as Secretary-General. It should not automatically be interpreted as a formally negotiated collective decision by all six GCC governments. No separate collective decision has been established in the available reporting.
That distinction matters because the GCC's credibility rests partly on its ability to uphold principles beyond the immediate interests of individual members.
Indeed, the timing makes the intervention particularly revealing. Just days earlier, Albudaiwi had addressed the United Nations Security Council, emphasizing sovereignty, territorial integrity, good neighborliness and non-interference in internal affairs. Those principles were presented as essential to regional peace and international stability.
Somalia is entitled to ask why those same principles received so little consideration when it raised complaints against a GCC member.
The Secretary-General could have acknowledged the UAE's economic and security contributions while affirming Somalia's sovereign rights. He could have called for direct consultations, transparent review of disputed agreements or mediation through established Arab and Islamic institutions.
Instead, his statement offered political reassurance to Abu Dhabi while providing little recognition of Mogadishu's concerns.
For an organization that frequently invokes international law, such selectivity carries reputational costs. It risks reinforcing the perception that sovereignty is defended vigorously when Gulf states are concerned, but treated as negotiable when smaller countries challenge their conduct.
Somalia can substantiate its allegations and pursue lawful diplomatic remedies. The UAE, for its part, should explain how its activities comply with Somalia's sovereignty and constitutional authority.
The GCC Secretary-General faces a different test: whether his institution can distinguish loyalty to a member from fairness toward another sovereign state.
The issue is not whether the GCC should abandon the UAE. It is whether solidarity with the UAE should come at the expense of the very principles the GCC claims to defend. International law cannot command credibility if its application depends on the political influence of the country invoking it.